Bar-av is one of the greatest goalkeepers in Edgewood College history, playing three years for the Eagles. During her first two seasons, Bar-av was named the NAC Defensive Player of the Year, while she landed on the First Team All-NAC in each of her three campaigns. In just three years, she compiled 226 saves, the fifth most in program history. She posted a 0.85 goals against average, which ranks second all-time. She also is second in Eagles history in wins (42) and shutouts (21). With Bar-av at keeper, the Eagles reached the 2008 NCAA Tournament thanks to two-consecutive shutouts in the conference tournament.