Oftedahl experienced great success with the men’s and women’s golf programs as head coach. He led the men’s program from 2000-2023 and the women’s program from 2008-2013. Oftedahl also served time with the women’s basketball program from 1998-2008. Under Oftedahl’s leadership, the Eagles men’s golf program recorded eight-straight runner-up finishes at the NACC Championships since the 2015-16 season. Since the 2006-07 season and through the 2022-23 campaign he coached 40 All-NACC players, five NACC medalists, three NACC Players of the Year, three NACC Freshman of the Year, and has won three NACC Coach of the Year awards. Oftedahl led the men’s golf program to conference championships and NCAA Championship appearances in 2013-14 and 2011-12.