Seiple holds the distinction of being the only Edgewood College student-athlete to be named the CapitalOne Academic All-American of the Year, an honor she achieved during her senior season in 2012. Seiple ranks second all-time in school history in points (223) and is one of just two Eagles players to reach 100 career goals, while scoring 23 game-winning goals during her time, which also ranks second in program history. She was a four-time First Team All-NAC player and was named the league's offensive player of the year twice. Seiple was a two-time Academic All-American and a three-time Academic All-District selection.